5 Thanksgiving Wine Strategies

4 glasses clinking above a roast turkey and table set for the holidays

If dinner is the star of Thanksgiving, drinks are the supporting player.

by Erin

Turkey may be the mascot of Thanksgiving, and you likely have visions of pumpkin pie dancing in your head, but you're certainly not welcoming your guests to your home with a glass of milk. At least not the ones over 19.

All the effort and focus that goes to planning and prepping and cooking and timing and serving The Feast. But drinks need attention, too.

Without the drinks – the welcome cocktail, the paired wines, the relaxing, after dinner tipple – the meal itself wouldn't be able to shine as brightly. Let's face it: there's a reason any movie scene taking place at the Thanksgiving table is set with the casually festive allure of scattered glasses and bottles strewn about. 

And your holiday wines deserve the same attention.

We've been helping hosts pull off delicious dinner parties for more than a decade; creating interesting menus and pairing great wines. We've learned a thing or two in that time, so follow our lead for stress-free strategies on serving holiday-worthy wine this Thanksgiving. 

What to Offer

This is a festive dinner – not a bar. There is no reason to run yourself ragged trying to pick up everyone's favourite wine. 

Keep your selection streamlined to a sparkling wine to greet guests and serve with appetizers, and a red and white wine for the dinner itself.

I like to go by what I call my, “3 Friendlies.” Crowd friendly, wallet friendly, and food friendly. These are bottles that most people will like, that also go well with most of what’s being served, and I can afford to serve several bottles of it throughout the evening.

A brut sparkling wine – perhaps a Crèmant from Burgundy or Luxemberg, is a delicious, food friendly option that comes in at $20 or less. A mid-weight white wine from a cool climate that a nice stream of acidity, such as a Chardonnay from northern Italy will go well with both the buttery, creamy foods plus cleanse your palate of the fat. Finally, a light, fruity red wine with soft tannins will complement the meats.

How Much to Offer

You never want to run out of wine. Ever. But especially not on a holiday, so do err on the side of generous.

Generally speaking, guests will have two drinks in the first hour and one every hour after that.

But for simplicities’ sake, estimating one bottle per person should be enough to get you through dinner and maybe even have a bit left over. 

Here’s an insider’s tip that will put you ahead of the game for future entertaining: buy a case of each. Thanksgiving is the starter’s pistol to the Season of Eating and Drinking, so even if you don't go through your stock this holiday, there's many more dinner parties to come. You will go through the bottles by the year's end, and maybe even save an extra trip to the wine store. 

When to Offer It

I’m a big fan of starting my parties with a welcome cocktail, like our seasonal Apple Cider Sour. But if that’s a bridge too far, adding extra steps to your already strained schedule, simply stick with the wines.

Greeting each guest with a glass of sparkling wine is festive and impressive (if you have the room, leave flutes and an open bottle on ice for a dramatic flair to set the tone). As the party wears on, bring out the whites and reds.

How to Serve It

For larger dinner parties like Thanksgiving, where I might get distracted in the kitchen, or pulled into a conversation and won’t notice a guest has run dry, I set up a bar (somewhere away from the kitchen or dining room).

While walking around with a bottle for top ups is charming and attentive when you can manage it, it’s annoying to keep the wine out of sight when you can’t be there lickety split to refill someone’s glass when they’re cornered in a conversation about why they’re single – still.

Perfect is the Enemy of Good

Trying to find that one, perfect, Thanksgiving wine is impossible - trust us. You will just make yourself crazy trying to find it.

From Brussels sprouts to sweet potatoes, there are so many flavours and textures on the Thanksgiving buffet, there simply isn’t going to be a one-size-fits-all bottle. As we note in Strategy #1, offer a red, white, and sparkling, and let guests pick their favourite.  

Be Gracious

Thanksgiving is not the time to convince your Great Aunt Ida to abandon her beloved white wine in favour of something else.

Inevitably, your will have people in your crowd that will only drink red, or only drink white, and debating wine choices, just like politics and religion, does not make for party pleasantries.

Who cares who the Pinot Noir just sings with the dark leg meat? Just pour them their wine preference and get back to having a good time.

Pace Yourself – and Everyone Else

Thanksgiving is a marathon, not a sprint. 

Considering most festive dinners of which we know begin in the afternoon and run well into the night, there's several hours of elbow-bending ahead. You don't want to be the amateur who passes out on the couch before the turkey is served.

Also, many of you will have more than one feast to attend, so arriving at the next day’s celebration with the booze flu is no fun for anyone.

Consider serving lower alcohol wines in the afternoon and reserving your big boys for the meal. Riesling, Gewurztraminer, and Prosecco are all naturally lower in alcohol, and will keep you fresh, bright, and classy for the day ahead. 

 

*This article was first published in 2015 and has been updated in 2022. 

 

 

 

 

Hear From Real People!

I wanted to thank you SO much for your tutored wine tasting! It was so much fun. You were both informative and hilarious! Each person said they would definitely recommend you to anyone looking to do a wine tasting!
Thank you very much for the amazing wine tasting. We all had the most wonderful time. The wines were excellent and your presentation was very entertaining and informative.
Our guests had a great evening and Erin made sure that everyone (even non-drinkers) enjoyed themselves! Thanks for making the bridal shower so memorable!
Everything was perfect and very personalized! We still talk about experience and how nice it was. Definitely memories our family will treasure forever.
Wow, Emily was absolutely fantastic! She was patient, explained the wines well, and was a delight to work with.

Thank you so much for everything I will definitely use your services again.
 
Everybody had a ton of fun and we very much see this structure as a template we can use with clients and friends in the future.
The unique programs and the tour we did with you was a huge success. Guests really enjoyed the afternoon!
You and your team were an absolute pleasure to work with! From the get go, you were very flexible with our needs, communicated in a timely manner, and tailored your services to be exactly what we asked for.
Great energy, sense of humour and very knowledgeable! Thank you for making it an afternoon to remember!
The event was a huge success! Everyone seemed to enjoy themselves and the group was quite engaged. The wine was also delicious! Thank you so much! I hope we can work together on another event in the future!

Instagram Feed

Follow on Instagram

For support issues or any questions, please email us at drinkwithus@thewinesisters.com

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to be the first to know about our wine recommendations, cocktail recipes, and great tips for throwing fabulous parties.